Do we choose the foods we eat, or do they choose us? The question may sound unconventional, but modern marketing appears to work wonders. It is no coincidence that analysts are increasingly focusing on the “health halo effect,” a mechanism that can have a decisive influence on consumers’ food choices. It creates the impression that people are making conscious, health-oriented decisions, when in reality the packaging has already shaped their perception of the product.
As Haris Dimosthenopoulos, a clinical dietitian and biologist who heads the Clinical Nutrition and Dietetics Department at Laiko General Hospital in Athens, explains to TA NEA, a single positive claim on a package can be enough to create this “halo,” leading consumers to believe they are buying a food product that is harmless from a nutritional standpoint.
“The Health Halo Effect is a cognitive bias whereby one positive characteristic of a food product leads us to consider the product healthy overall. For example, when we see the phrase ‘no added sugar,’ we may automatically assume that the food is low in calories or that we can consume it freely. In reality, however, it may contain significant amounts of fat, calories or naturally occurring sugars.”
There are many similar examples on the market, often leaving consumers with an idealized picture of the products they buy that bears little resemblance to reality.
“We are living in an era in which foods choose consumers, rather than the other way around. Every package has front-of-pack labeling and back-of-pack labeling. The real information is on the latter, but the former is what consumers see on the shelf. Descriptions featuring words such as ‘free from,’ ‘free’ and ‘pure’ usually reveal only one aspect of a food product, not the full picture,” says George Boskou, professor of Food Service Organization and Management at Harokopio University in Athens.
Nutritional Deception
After all, not everything that glitters is nutritional gold. Removing one ingredient, such as sugar or a preservative, often means adding other substances to maintain a product’s taste, texture, color or shelf life.
The examples Boskou provides are telling.
“When processed meat products are made with less salt, this automatically creates a preservation and food safety problem, since pathogenic bacteria may develop. Another type of processing, primarily heat treatment, must therefore be applied. Similarly, a gluten-free baked product may contain baking additives, since gluten is what makes bread rise. A fat-free or low-fat product may contain more carbohydrates, while ‘sugar-free’ cookies with fruit pieces may ultimately contain more simple sugars derived from dried fruit.”
The professor also includes other claims that may be misleading. For example, a product labeled “palm oil free” is not necessarily free of saturated fats. Similarly, breadsticks described as “made with olive oil” may actually contain seed oils as their main ingredient, with a small amount of olive oil added to the recipe to justify the claim on the packaging.
In yogurt desserts, meanwhile, consumers may find the label “source of protein,” even though all conventional yogurts are sources of protein.
Dimosthenopoulos, for his part, compares sugar-free chocolate with conventional chocolate. The former may contain sweeteners such as maltitol, as well as a significant amount of cocoa butter.
“As a result, it may provide 500 kcal per 100 grams, compared with 530 kcal per 100 grams for conventional chocolate. The difference in calories is small, despite the substantial difference in sugar content. In addition, excessive consumption of certain polyols, such as maltitol, can cause bloating or diarrhea.”
“Natural,” “Organic,” but Not Necessarily Harmless
Can an organic product also be a diet-friendly one? Yes, but not necessarily.
Nevertheless, a 2025 study concluded that although one claim does not imply the other, consumers often make the connection automatically, even when there is no scientific basis for doing so. As a result, an organic label can encourage people to overconsume foods that are particularly high in fat and sugar, with all the health implications that entails.
More specifically, French scientists conducted a systematic review of the available literature, examining 10 scientific articles covering 21 individual studies. They confirmed that organic labeling consistently leads consumers to underestimate the calorie content of food. In other words, when an unhealthy product carries an “organic” label, consumers tend to mentally discount some of its calories.
In light of these findings, the authors stress that, because this cognitive bias can lead to overconsumption and, consequently, may be associated with an increased risk of obesity, changes in health policy are needed.
Among other measures, they propose wider adoption of food labeling systems such as Nutri-Score, which would allow consumers to recognize at a glance that a product may be organic while also being high in fat or sugar.
A Picture Is Worth a Thousand Words
Meanwhile, an earlier study reached similar conclusions, confirming just how effective the health halo can be in promoting products.
Published in the journal Food Quality and Preference in 2021, the study found that packaging can be entirely legal and formally compliant while still misleading consumers. This is because lawmakers focus on the wording and scientific accuracy of claims, whereas consumers process packaging information in just a few seconds, relying on automatic psychological responses.
For example, regulations allow a product to carry a scientifically approved claim such as “source of calcium” or “with vitamin D.” And although the manufacturer is not making a false claim, consumers may still fall victim to the health halo effect.
How? When they see the word “calcium” on a chocolate-flavored drink or dessert, they may overlook the fact that the sweetened product contains, for example, 30 grams of sugar, instead perceiving it as beneficial to their overall health.
The researchers offer another revealing example: mass-produced, factory-made sandwich bread packaged in a brown paper bag with a font designed to resemble handwriting. Consumers perceive the product as “traditional” – as though it had been kneaded and baked in their neighborhood bakery – even though the back of the package lists numerous preservatives.
And so, the image created by packaging can prove more powerful than the information printed on it.







