This is not a generation that does not want to work. It is a generation that, increasingly, cannot find somewhere to work, a way into education or someone to turn to when their lives begin to unravel. Behind the administrative acronym NEET, describing young people not in education, employment or training, lies one of the most serious social challenges facing modern Britain.
Almost one million people aged 16 to 24 are now outside education, employment or training. Six in ten have never had a job. In 2005, the figure was four in ten. This is more than a statistic measuring unemployment. It points to a growing number of young people for whom the transition from adolescence to adulthood can no longer be taken for granted.
A review by Alan Milburn, a former Labour Health Secretary, entitled From a Welfare State to a Working State, published on 17 November, examines why Britain’s system is failing to keep the younger generation connected to education and employment. It warns that, without radical change, the country risks creating a lost generation.
‘They do not want to be NEET’
Milburn challenges the very terminology used by the state to describe these young people. During one of his meetings, a young woman told him they should not be described as people who were ‘not in education, employment or training’, but rather as young people who were ‘desperate for education, employment and training’.
‘I have not found a single one of them who wanted to be NEET. Not one,’ he writes.
That observation lies at the heart of the review. The problem, he argues, is not a lack of ambition or willingness to make an effort, but a lack of genuine opportunities.
The failure also carries a substantial economic cost. Milburn estimates the cumulative annual cost to the British economy at around £125bn, taking into account the consequences for employment, public finances and productivity. Long-term detachment from the labour market deprives young people of income, confidence and independence, while increasing the likelihood that they will become trapped in a cycle of economic and social insecurity.
The health crisis behind unemployment
One of the review’s central findings is that the crisis cannot be treated simply as an employment problem. Growing numbers of young people are excluded from the labour market because of ill health or disability, with mental health playing a particularly significant role.
According to Milburn, Britain’s health system is too heavily focused on treatment and not enough on prevention. Long waiting lists for mental health services mean that a young person may wait months for support, becoming increasingly disconnected from school, training or work in the meantime.
The review calls for guaranteed access to psychological support and talking therapies within three months, even without a formal diagnosis. It also proposes digital mental health services and national maximum waiting times from 2028. The objective is to intervene before illness develops into permanent exclusion from economic and social life.
The housing crisis and the rising cost of living compound the problem. For young people without financial support from their families, becoming independent is increasingly difficult. The inability to afford rent, mounting debts and financial insecurity can undermine even the most determined efforts to return to education or employment.
Milburn therefore argues for a personalised approach that takes account not only of someone’s employment status, but also their housing situation, financial pressures and health.
A radical overhaul of the welfare state
Milburn’s proposals are ambitious and extend across almost every area of public policy. The target is to reduce the proportion of young people classified as NEET from around 13 per cent to approximately 5 per cent by 2036.
In education, he proposes that schools identify pupils at risk of disengagement at an early stage, provide compulsory work experience and be assessed partly on the employment and educational destinations of their former pupils. He also calls for an additional 150,000 places on further education courses each year and a doubling of the number of young people completing apprenticeships over the next decade.
At the centre of the proposals is a new Opportunity Guarantee, under which every young person would have the right to a pathway into education, training or employment. A new locally based support service would provide individual guidance, with each young person assigned a named adviser and a personalised action plan.
Employers would also receive financial incentives. The review proposes a £3,000 payment for businesses recruiting young people who have been out of education and employment for at least six months, with additional support for small businesses and for hiring disabled young people or those with experience of being in care.
The most controversial element, however, concerns the welfare system. Milburn proposes an entirely new benefits system for under-25s, removing the health-related top-up to Universal Credit and access to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) for this age group. Existing support would be replaced by a new Youth Allowance, with additional targeted assistance for those facing significant and ongoing disability-related costs.
The political battle over benefit cuts
The Government of Prime Minister Andy Burnham has described the review as a turning point. Burnham argues that the crisis requires wholesale reform rather than simply cuts to welfare payments.
‘Nobody can be comfortable with the idea of hundreds of thousands of young people on benefits,’ he has said, insisting that tackling the problem requires meaningful support rather than straightforward reductions in spending.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has accused the Government of attempting to address problems of its own making through expensive state-funded schemes. She wants to reduce the cost of hiring young workers, arguing that businesses need fewer disincentives to recruitment rather than further government intervention.
From a different political perspective, Green Party leader Zack Polanski has warned that the proposed changes risk hitting the most vulnerable. Disability rights organisations have voiced even stronger opposition, arguing that removing existing benefits could push young people into poverty, homelessness and further deterioration in their health.
The financial challenge is equally significant. The proposed measures require additional spending running into billions of pounds each year. Despite projected savings from lower benefit payments and increased employment, the net fiscal benefit is expected to be relatively modest. The Government must therefore demonstrate that it can invest now without transferring the burden onto those least able to bear it.
Britain’s experience offers a wider lesson: tackling youth unemployment cannot be reduced to training programmes or temporary financial incentives. It requires schools, universities, health services, employers and government to work together, creating genuine jobs and providing meaningful support.
Milburn ends his review with a warning that extends well beyond Britain’s borders: ‘A lost generation is not a fact of life. It is a choice. And I believe it is the wrong one.’
The question is no longer whether young people want to work and build lives of their own. It is whether governments are prepared to give them the conditions in which to do so.






